Are you a fan of delicious Italian cuisine? If the answer is yes, then one ingredient that can't be missed is olive oil.

Olive oil is an essential part of many Italian dishes, whether it's simple bruschetta or lasagna with pesto.

And while there are plenty of store-bought options available these days, the best quality comes from olive oils sourced directly from Italy.

In this blog post, we'll explore some of the tastiest and most sought after Italian extra-virgin and cold-pressed olives oils on the market today.

We'll delve into the history behind each type of Italian best olive oil and why they're so beloved by chefs around the world so that you can choose wisely when making your next flavorful meal!

How We Choose the Best Italian Olive Oil

We hope you find the product that works great for you from the list below! Each product was independently selected by our editors.

Some may have been sent as samples for us to try out, but all opinions in this article are our own.

Oh, and FYI — EasyHealthHacks may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy something (that's how we stay in business).

We hope you enjoy the extensive research we've done to find the top picks on Amazon so you don't have to!

Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

We love Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil for its bold flavor profile, versatility, and ability to add an authentic Italian touch to any dish.

We especially love the history behind this product and the fact that it is crafted from olives harvested in Sicily by four generations of the Asaro family.

Best of all, you can be sure you are eating healthy as this organic extra virgin olive oil is rich in antioxidants and naturally produced phenols that promote vascular health and physical well-being.

So don’t hesitate to try Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil today to bring the flavor of Sicily right into your kitchen.

The best Italian extra virgin olive oils have never tasted so good!

What You Should Know

When buying Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil, remember that it comes in a 34-ounce tin.

This oil will stay fresh for up to 18 months after opening as it is bottled and stored in a dark-coated steel can so light cannot enter and spoil the product.

When you first open the Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil tin, it will be cloudy with a green hue.

As the oil ages, it will mellow slightly and become clearer as the sediment drops to the bottom of the tin.

Finally, you can use Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil for cooking vegetables, pasta, dipping, and finishing dishes.

It has a herbaceous aroma, fruity flavor and ‘pizzicante’ flavor – an Italian phrase for olive oil producers a strong taste that grips the back of your throat.

Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin

Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Papa Vince is one of the best Italian Olive Oils you can find.

Their family’s commitment to authenticity, transparency, and premium quality ingredients has enabled them to craft an olive oil production that will surely delight your taste buds!

Its high polyphenol content makes it incredibly healthy - perfect for any diet or lifestyle.

With its delicious flavor and abundant vitamins and minerals, Papa Vince's Italian Olive Oil is a must-have for any kitchen.

What You Should Know

Before buying Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin, it’s important to understand what makes it so good. Here are some key facts:

Made from organic olives locally grown by their family in Sicily.

High in polyphenols - 420 mg/kg at the time of bottling.

High in vitamin E (DV 20%) & K (DV 6%).

Unfiltered oils and unrefined oils - 100% the fresh juice of the fruit of the olive trees.

Polyphenol-rich olive oil - contains naturally occurring polyphenols.

We believe that choosing Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a decision you won’t regret.

With its exceptional flavor and nutrition, you can enjoy delicious dishes with a true Italian flair.

AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

AmazonFresh's Cold Extracted blend is made with 100% Italian olives and has been pressed and bottled in Italy.

Its smooth flavor has subtle notes of pepper and herbs, making it the perfect choice for cooking with pasta, grilling, vegetables, salad dressing, and finishing dishes.

Best of all, it comes in a 2-liter bottle to have your favorite Italian olive oil on hand for any recipe.

What You Should Know

Before buying AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil, you should know it is non-GMO and gluten-free.

It's important to know that this best extra virgin olive oil has a Best by Date printed on the bottle. Be sure to use it within six months of opening.

If you like Colavita Premium Italian Extra Virgin Oil, AmazonFresh’s blend is an ideal alternative.

With its cold extraction process and notes of pepper and fresh herbs, you can cook and finish your dishes with this premium Italian Olive Oil.

Tuscany IGP High Polyphenols (+600mg/kg) Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Tuscany IGP High Polyphenols (+600mg/kg) Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

We love Tuscany IGP High Polyphenols Olive Oil Extra Virgin because of its unique flavor profile.

The perfect combination of high polyphenol content, superior taste, and quality, plus its practical container, make this organic extra virgin olive oil really one of a kind.

Not to mention its incredibly versatile uses and pairings for any cuisine!

We also love that it is from a family estate and 100% pesticides free.

It's the perfect olive oil gift for any occasion!

What You Should Know

When buying Tuscany Italian Olive Oil, make sure to purchase the Tuscany IGP High Polyphenols Olive Oil Extra Virgin.

It's certified origin Tuscan olive oil that is first cold pressed and has a high phenolic content above 600 mg/kg.

Not only will you be getting an incredible product, but it's also perfect as a gift because of its functional container.

With Tuscany IGP High Polyphenols Olive Oil Extra Virgin, you'll surely get the Best Italian Olive Oil you deserve.

Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a great quality extra virgin olive oil.

Its unique intense aroma and delicate fruity taste make it an excellent addition to any dish.

This Italian extra virgin olive oil brand is also organic and cold-pressed, ensuring it retains all its health benefits and delicious flavors.

The Frantoi Cutrera Primo is a Best Italian Olive Oil award winner, so you know it's one of the very best olive oils out there!

We highly recommend adding this amazing olive oil to your pantry for an incomparable addition to any dish.

The unique taste and mild, delicate yet intense aroma will make all the difference in your cooking.

What You Should Know

When buying olive oil, looking for cold-pressed and organic olive oils, is important.

The Frantoi Cutrera Primo Olive Oil is both, ensuring its quality and flavor remain strong.

This Best Italian Olive Oil award winner is also a great choice because its flavor is mild and won't overpower the taste of your food.

It's an unbeatable Italian Olive Oil award winner, and its unique flavor will make all your dishes stand out.

Monini DOP Umbria Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Monini DOP Umbria Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Welcome to Monini, a trusted source of the very best in extra virgin Umbria olive oil, sourced only from Umbria in Italy.

Their PDO certified olive oil has a vintage bouquet and a wooden hint that makes it truly special.

As part of their commitment to reliability and authenticity, they carefully select the highest quality olives from different regions of Italy to craft their unique flavors and fragrances of oil.

This makes Monini DOP Umbria Extra Virgin Olive Oil perfect for any recipe – whether you’re making tasty game dishes, preparing hearty grilled meats, or just looking for flavorful ingredients for vegetable soups.

They take pride in offering such high-quality products that you can incorporate into homemade meals.

What You Should Know

At Monini, they apply strict professional principles of reliability and authenticity so that you can be sure to enjoy the same consistent quality no matter which of their olive oils you choose.

With their expertise they’re able to present some truly exceptional extra virgin olive oils that are sure to exceed all expectations and make you fall in love with Mediterranean cooking!

Find your own personal favorite—that ultimate flavor experience that elevates everyday food into something special—with Monini’s DOP Umbria Extra Virgin Olive Oil.


What makes a good olive oil?

The best olive oils are made from olives that have been freshly harvested and cold-pressed, producing a high-quality oil that is full of flavor and health benefits.

The best Italian olive oils contain natural antioxidants, polyphenols, and vitamins A, D, E, and K. They also have low acidity levels, which helps preserve the oil's flavor and freshness.

How can you tell if olive oil is high quality?

High-quality olive oils will have a bright green or golden-yellow color, with an intense aroma and a pleasant flavor.

A good indication of the quality of an oil is its Best-Before date; the best Italian olive oils should last up to two years after their Best-Before date.

The acidity levels of the top italian olive oil brand are also important; the lower the acidity of other olive oils, the better the quality of Italian olive oil brands is likely to be.

Finally, look out for certifications such as PDO (Protected Designation of Origin) or PGI (Protected Geographical Indication), awarded to olive oils of outstanding quality.

What are the benefits of using olive oil?

Olive oil is a healthy fat that can help reduce the risk of heart disease, lower cholesterol levels, and promote healthy skin.

It's also packed with antioxidants and anti-inflammatory properties that can help protect against debilitating diseases such as Alzheimer’s.*

How do you choose olive oil?

When selecting Italian olive oil, look for oils that have been cold-pressed and are certified PDO or PGI.

Check for Best-Before dates on olive varieties to ensure freshness, and opt for extra virgin olive oil if flavor is your priority.

When tasting an oil, look for intense aromas and flavors of fish, meat, freshly cut grass, artichoke, or tomato leaves to determine its quality.

Finally, consider the acidity level; the lower, the better!

Summing It All Up

Italy is home to some of the finest olive trees and olive groves in the world, lovingly crafted by passionate producers determined to give you a truly unique gastronomic experience.

With the incredible variety of olive oil across different regions of Italy, it's easy to see why Italians have become known for their incredible culinary ability.

Olive oils range in flavor and texture, providing endless combinations and recipes to explore.

Each Italian region has something unique to offer with its own special twist on their renowned olive oil.

While there may be no definitive answer as to which is the best Italian olive oil, those who are open to exploring them all will find nothing but delight in experiencing these unique flavors and aromas of Italy.

So there you have it! All that's left is to head over to Amazon and check out the brand you think is best for you - thanks for stopping by, and be sure to check out our other blog posts for more information on living a healthy life!

*The statements in this article have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This article is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.